The Contest Between PUR And PIR in The Rigid Foam Market, A Evenly Matched Comparison

Dec 22, 2024 Leave a message

The difference between PUR and PIR

To put it simply; PUR is the equivalent reaction of polyols and isocyanates to form foams. PIR is the abbreviation of English polyisocyanurate, which is a kind of foams containing typical carbon and nitrogen six-membered rigid heterocyclic ring characteristic structure.PIR is an excessive reaction of isocyanates. Isocyanates can react with foaming agents without adding polyols by adding a special metal salt catalyst. However, because the brittleness is too great, it has no practical value, so people add low-hydroxyl polyols through modification to improve the brittleness of the foam.


Advantages of PIR over PUR:

(1) The fire resistance of PIR is better than that of PUR.PUR and PIR are two foam systems. Polyols are divided into polyether polyols and polyester polyols. PUR is a foam system formed by the reaction of polyether polyols with isocyanates. PIR is formed by the reaction of polyester polyols with isocyanates.Among them, the isocyanate index of the PUR sheet is usually between 110 and 120, and the degree of crosslinking in the PUR foam system mainly depends on the function of the polyether polyol.However, with the increasingly stringent requirements for fire rating, PUR foams face huge challenges in meeting fire protection specifications. Usually, in order to meet the requirements of fire protection specifications, a large number of flame-retardant agents will be added to the formula system, but at the same time it will affect the compressive strength and dimensional stability of the foam and other physical properties, and increase the cost of the product.The degree of crosslinking of the PIR system depends on the trimerization reaction of excess isocyanate. Usually, the isocyanate index reaches 200 to 300. Under the action of the corresponding catalyst, the excess isocyanate can self-react to generate a six-membered ring, which provides crosslinking to the foam system. At the same time, it also promotes combustion and coking into carbon through its own six-membered ring molecular structure, which improves the fire resistance of the foam system.
(2) The PIR reaction is simple and low-cost raw materials can be used.;
(3) PIR can give the product better dimensional stability at high and low temperatures, lower thermal decomposition rate, and a protective carbon layer can be formed during combustion.;
(4) The mechanical strength of PIR is better than that of PUR;
(5) The production efficiency of PIR is high.

The deficiency of PIR relative to PUR:

(1) High brittleness and lower fluidity than PUR;
(2) The adhesion is poor, and the adhesion to the surface material is only 1/2 of the PUR.;
(3) PIR has the performance of rapid secondary foaming, which will affect the performance of the surface of the sheet.;
(4) The surface maturation is poor, and the later maturation is late;
(5) The process range is narrow (the production temperature is higher than 60℃), and the production is more difficult to control.In continuous PIR sheet production, the control of equipment and the external environment is essential to the quality of the final product. It is necessary to carry out good temperature control of various chemical raw materials, because this has a huge impact on the stability of the entire chemical reaction process and the entire foam forming process.

PIR requirements for equipment:

(1) The preheating temperature of the double track is greater than 70℃;
(2) The length of the double track is greater than 30 meters to ensure the maturation time;
(3) Must be equipped with a plate cooling device.